Home › Repair or Replace?
A $900 repair on a $290,000 house with eight good years left in the roof is the right call. So is a $14,000 replacement on a roof that has had three patches since Beryl. The difference is in six things the roofer can see, and none of them is how persuasive the estimate is.
Look at when Spring was built. ZIP 77379 has 8,091 homes from the 1990s, 6,326 from the 1970s, 4,853 from the 1980s, 4,520 from the 1960s and only 4,802 from the 2000s, by unitedstateszipcodes.org’s count. In 77388, 35 percent of the housing dates from the 1960s and 1970s. That is not one housing stock. It is an old-heavy mix in which a large share of roofs are on their second or third cycle, which changes the math completely: on a third roof, the decking, the old overlay and the fifteen years of flashing repairs that came before matter more than any shingle warranty.
Now look at the money. Median household income is $110,712 in 77379 and $101,588 in 77388; median home values are $335,900 and $264,600. This is a mid-market suburb. The decision in front of a Memorial Northwest homeowner is not which premium material to choose. It is whether to spend the price of a used car on a roof that might have years left. A site that answers every question with “replace” is not serving that homeowner, and a roofer who does the same is not either.
A roof does not fail on its warranty date. It fails when the granules that shade the asphalt wear off, when the seal strip under each tab lets go, and when the mat goes brittle enough to crack under a footstep. A roofer walking the roof can see all three. If the granules are largely present, the tabs are down and the shingle bends without cracking, the roof has years in it and the problem in front of you is a repair. If the roofer’s boots leave bare patches and the tabs lift at a touch, no repair holds for long, because the next weak spot is two feet away.
A limb puncture in Champion Forest, a split pipe boot in Northampton, a valley in Cypresswood packed with needles: each is one thing, with edges, in a roof that is otherwise doing its job. That is a repair, and in Spring it is the most common verdict. The other case is a field failure: granule loss across whole slopes, cupping along the south exposure, tabs breaking off in wind that should not have moved them. There the leak you called about is only the first of several, and patching it buys months.
This is the row that separates Spring from a new-construction market. A 1976 house in Champion Forest may have plank decking with gaps, or the first generation of sheathing that has now been through two roofs and fifty summers of attic heat. Around a leak, that decking is often soft. A repair can be made into sound wood; it cannot be made into wood that will not hold a nail. When a roofer opens a section and finds the decking gone across the slope, a repair stops being an option, and a replacement quote should include what the decking will need, not discover it on tear-off day.
Overlays were common on second roofs. A house that got its second roof laid over the first in the 1990s has two layers of shingle, and a repair on top of two layers is guesswork: the flashing cannot be reset properly, the patch sits proud, and the roofer cannot see the decking at all. Two layers also means the next roof is a full tear-off whatever else happens. If you do not know whether there is an overlay, ask the roofer to check at the rake edge. It takes a minute.
A leak that traces to one entry point is a repair. Most Spring leaks do: a valley, a wall flashing where the second story meets a lower roof, a skylight curb, a pipe boot. When water is showing up in two rooms on different sides of the house in the same season, the roof is telling you something about the whole field, and row two applies. The attic is where this gets settled, with a flashlight, in daylight, and it takes an hour.
Repairs on a Spring roof typically run from the hundreds into the low thousands, depending on how much has to come off to get at the problem. A replacement on a typical two-story here is a five-figure job, more if the decking needs work. The question is not which is cheaper today. It is what has already been spent: if the last three years of repairs add up to a meaningful share of a replacement and the roof is still failing, the repairs are paying for a roof you are not getting. If one repair buys several quiet years, it was the right money.
Ask for it in writing, with photos, and expect it to name the row. “Repair: single limb puncture on the rear slope, decking sound, one layer, shingles have granules and seal, estimated remaining life eight to ten years” is a verdict. “Replace: field failure on the south and west slopes, two layers confirmed at rake, soft decking at the valley, three repairs in the last four years” is also a verdict. “Your roof is old, you should replace it” is not, and in this market it is the sentence to push back on.
The same six rows work for siding. Hardboard that is soft along the bottom laps of one shaded gable is a section repair. Hardboard that is swollen at every butt joint across the rear elevation, with paint that will not hold, is a replacement for that elevation, and usually only that elevation, because the front of a Spring house is brick.
There is no number. A 22-year-old roof with good granules on a shaded slope may take a repair; a 14-year-old builder-grade roof that has baked on a south slope may not. The roofer reads the shingles, not the calendar.
Not reliably. Granule loss, seal-strip failure and soft decking are all things you feel underfoot. Ask for photos from the roof and from inside the attic.
Ask each one which row of the table their verdict rests on. A replacement recommendation that cannot name a failed field, bad decking or an overlay is a sales call.
A local roofer looks at the six things, writes down what they found, and tells you which it is.
Call (832) 447-6614 Ask for a Verdict
Spring Roofing